Reviews and Comments

Nick Barlow

Nickbwalking@ramblingreaders.org

Joined 1 year, 5 months ago

I read a lot, and try to keep things varied and am always interested in broadening my outlook through something new. Currently writing a memoir about walking, mental health, and grief. Can be found elsewhere on the fediverse talking about things other than books at nickbwalking@zirk.us and nickbwalking@me.dm

This link opens in a pop-up window

The Kaiju Preservation Society (EBook, 2022, Tom Doherty Associates) 3 stars

Jamie’s dream was to hit the big time at a New York tech start-up. Jamie’s …

Popcorn, but good popcorn

3 stars

As Scalzi says in his afterword, this is a three-minute pop song of a novel, not a complex symphony. However, even the lightest of pop songs needs effort to make it work, and this does work on its own terms. It's a fun book that rattles along at a good pace, throwing enough big ideas into the mix to keep you reading and not asking too many questions about whether it all makes sense. Spends a lot of time setting up for not much plot, and relies a lot on coincidences to give the ending a personal stake for the protagonist, but does what it says on the tin and people who like this sort of thing will like this.

Nomadland (2017) 4 stars

"From the beet fields of North Dakota to the National Forest campgrounds of California to …

Welcome to the future

4 stars

On one level, this book shows its origins in magazine articles as it skips around a bunch of views of the same topic, and repeats itself a few times (the Rubber Tramp Rendezvous is introduced several times, for instance), but it works because the subject matter is so strong. I'd not seen the film of this, so while I knew about people living in vans, I wasn't aware of just how many there were in the US, nor how old a lot of them were. It's a recreation of a past way of life on the road, but also a signal of what awaits us all, living with less and less and heading back and forth across the country at the beck and call of billionaires and corporations that only see humans as another factor of production, there to be exploited as much as possible. It should be a call …

A Memory Called Empire (Paperback, 2020, Pan Macmillan) 4 stars

Won the 2020 Hugo for Best Novel. Ambassador Mahit Dzmare is posted far from her …

Politics as war by other means

4 stars

What do you do when your homeland is in the path of an expanding empire, hungry to consume it and draw it into its embrace? That's the central question to this, and it tells a fascinating story of Mahit Dzamare, sent to the imperial capital as an ambassador to try to protect her home, but also to find out what happened to her predecessor. There's a lot of palace intrigue that she has to figure out, but also a wider set of political processes going on outside the confines of the court, and it's good to see a recognition of those political structures and movements in a book like this. Sometimes feels like there's too much going on - I haven't even touched on the Mahit's internal story, as she deals with an outdated copy of her predecessors mind within her own - but it all comes together in a …

The Thousand Earths (EBook, 2022, Gollancz) 2 stars

Paper-thin characters in a potentially interesting setting

2 stars

There's a really interesting idea at the heart of this - the Thousand Earths, a grouping of flat discs of land, each one slowly dissolving from the edge - but the book doesn't do justice to it. The characters are flat, and the storytelling is very "and then this thing happened, and then this thing" with no real sense of the characters outside of their plot function. It's also interspersed with a second tale which could almost be someone parodying a typical Baxter hero: an American astronaut on a long long voyage, who seems to want nothing more than to find someone to moan at that the future isn't what he expected it to be.

The House of Wisdom (Hardcover, 2011, Penguin Press) 4 stars

Interesting account of a neglected piece of history

4 stars

(The version I read was called Pathfinders, but I believe it's the same book, just has a different title in the UK) Second book I've read on this topic this year, but this is the more interesting one. It focuses more on the story of how Arabic science developed, especially how Baghdad became a centre of learning and discovery first through the translation movement processing Greek and Roman texts, then moving into their own age of discovery. There's a series of interesting profiles of key figures in different fields, looking at how they moved things forward, but the book also looks at the wider history going on, and how this happened within the development and expansion of the Islamic world. Only at the end does he move on to how this influenced later Western science, so it's not the focus of the book but an interesting addition. Could have been …

The Rise of Endymion (Paperback, 1998, Spectra) 2 stars

The future of humanity is at stake? Yes, but have you considered my manpain?

2 stars

I enjoyed the first part of this, when things that had been set up in the previous books were finally paying off and there was a sense of things coming to a crisis point out of anyone's control. Then the plot skipped forwards a few years and we had to focus on Raul's whining for far too long. The main revelations all come about through someone infodumping them because we can't reveal them through plot when all that space is being taken up by Raul having a crisis because while he's having wonderful, amazing, sex with the girl he's known since she was 11 (and yes, ewww to that whole thing) she might have had a relationship with someone else, and we can't have her having her own agency. Then we might have to treat her as a character, not a plot function, and that won't do. Add in a …

SPQR: A History of Ancient Rome (2015) 4 stars

SPQR: A History of Ancient Rome is a 2015 book by English classicist Mary Beard …

A good introduction to Roman history, but not much more

3 stars

I know that Mary Beard knows a lot more about Roman history than I do, but I don't think a general history like this shows off her knowledge in the best way. It's simply trying to cover too much in one modest volume, even though she chooses the (somewhat arbitrary) cutoff point of the early third century CE for an ending.

There's a lot that gets covered here - social, political, military, cultural and other forms of history all show up - but too much to make the story coherent so it's more a series of roughly-linked vignettes, rather than an overall history. It might have worked better by having a better focus on a few of the interesting stories she tells (and Beard is a good writer and storyteller) rather than trying to make it into an overarching history.

Gideon the Ninth (EBook, 2019, Doherty Associates, LLC, Tom) 4 stars

"The Emperor needs necromancers.

The Ninth Necromancer needs a swordswoman.

Gideon has a sword, some …

Those who like this sort of thing...

3 stars

I've seen a lot of people raving about this and I was curious to try it, so was glad when it came up as a text for a book club I'm in. Having now finished it, I can see why some people really love it, but it's not really for me. It plunges you straight into the universe and it's overwhelming and bewildering for a long time as there's nothing too familiar to ground yourself on and work out what's going on. It's very stylised, with a strong authorial voice, which I don't mind, but information is doled out very slowly, both to the characters and the reader, so it does feel like wandering around in the dark a lot. The ending does reveal a lot of things that help to make sense of what's gone on before, but you need to cling on in faith that it's going to …

Delicacy (Paperback, 2022, Headline Publishing Group) 5 stars

A moving memoir about grief and loss

5 stars

This was an interesting memoir, and one that really resonated for me because, like Wix, I've lost relatives to dementia and brain tumours, so I could strongly relate both to her stories of losing them and how to deal with the grief that comes over you after that. It covers a lot of ground other than that, though, and structuring it around memories of cake is an interesting way to frame a life, but it brings in her other themes of body image and mental health. It's easy for a story like this to sprawl into lots of different parts that don't cohere or just become a series of anecdotes, but there's a strong shape to this even if it only comes together towards the end as she begins to understand and process everything that's happened to her. One thing worth noting is that yes, this is Katy Wix the …

Conspiracy: A History of Boll*cks Theories, and How Not to Fall for Them 3 stars

Only skims the surface

3 stars

(Disclaimer: I've known Jonn Elledge through social media and fandom for a while, but I bought this book) The main issue I have with this book is that it isn't really sure what it wants to be. There's a really interesting essay in the middle of it about the history of health and pandemic related conspiracies, but it's surrounded by some very surface-skimming summaries of other conspiracy theories that don't really get examined in any great depth. When they go in depth, it works well, but the rest feels like reading Wikipedia while someone rehearses a bunch of jokes at you - some of the asides are amusing, but there are too many of them and they feel like they're they're in place of any analysis of what this all means.

Endymion (Paperback, 1996, Bantam Books) 2 stars

The multiple-award-winning SF master returns to the universe that is his greatest success--the world of …

Fascinating universe, dull plot

2 stars

Content warning Some plot stuff, sexualisation of a minor

Lying for Money (2022, Scribner) 5 stars

Accessible and amusing guide to financial fraud

5 stars

(Disclaimer: I've known the author through blogs and social media for a long time, though I got this book from the library) I wouldn't normally expect to find myself laughing out loud while reading about complex financial matters, but I did several times during this book. It would be very easy for this to be quite a leaden and dry tome, a financial expert explaining frauds and financial crimes to us plebs in a vaguely patronising manner. Despite a long career as a financial analyst though, Davies has kept his sense of perspective as well as his sense of humour and gives us a tour of some massive frauds to explain to us just what was going on that made them criminal as well as what tempts someone into attempting fraud. He's also refreshingly honest at talking about how analysts like him have missed frauds that were obvious in retrospect …

Silver in the Wood (Paperback, 2019, Tom Doherty Associates) 4 stars

There is a Wild Man who lives in the deep quiet of Greenhollow, and he …

Short, but absorbing

4 stars

A small tale, this one, but a good one. It's a story about an old wood, its guardian and the newcomer who stumbles into it, but like an old tree there are layers and layers under that surface, knotted together to be revealed throughout. Well worth reading, and I hope yo see more from Emily Tesh in the future. (Oh, and the acknowledgements mention an early version on AO3, so I'm curious about where this story grew from)

Africa Is Not a Country (2022, Norton & Company Limited, W. W.) 4 stars

A book to learn from

4 stars

At times l, this book burns with a righteous anger, at others it shines with joy and humour, in still others it frustrates with a scattergun lack of focus. In those bright and angry moments, though, it's something to learn from. Great discussions of how 'Africa' has been created in Western media, and how the cultural treasures of the real Africa have been looted to museums in the rest of the world.

A Certain Idea of France: The Life of Charles de Gaulle (2018) 5 stars

Exceptional biography

5 stars

This is a massive book, but it rarely feels like it doesn't justify its size. De Gaulle's life is examined in detail, but it's not just a listing of the facts. Jackson is seeking to explain why this one man became such an emblematic symbol of France, looking at how chance collided with his sense of destiny in 1940 to leave him alone in London yet claiming to be the last one who could speak for France. He captures the fluidity of the time impressively, not treating anything as inevitable but showing the contingencies De Gaulle faced along the way. There's a slight feeling of it pestering out towards the end, but that's a reflection of its subject failing to find a new purpose after the Algerian crisis was settled. Well worth reading for anyone with an interest in French history.